12 Truly Unique Things to Do in Chicago: Windy City’s Best-Kept Secrets, According to the Internet Underground

The problem with most guides about Chicago is that they show you what everyone else has already come to see. Navy Pier. The Bean. Magnificent Mile. Deep dish pizza you had to wait 90 minutes in line to eat.

But there’s another Chicago, one shared between locals in quiet conversations and online forums, or buried deep in a tweet from someone who found a falafel shop through the back of a jewelry shop.

It’s a city of hidden rooms, forgotten cemeteries, interactive theater, and museums so specific they border on surreal. These are places with texture and sometimes just enough weirdness to make you look twice.

This guide is built from those digital backchannels and personal footnotes: discussions pulled from Reddit, X, and local whispers that reveal what people actually love and what they’re trying to keep just out of view.

The only thing you won’t find here is a line of tourists waiting for the same photo.

🛎️ Start Your Chicago Adventure with Sonesta Hotels

Time Capsules & Pocket Dimensions: For Travelers Drawn to the Surreal

Chicago, beneath its grid of high-rises and steakhouses, hides a quiet sub-layer of spaces that seem to operate in another dimension entirely.

Here, the scale shifts. Time slows. And you’re no longer sure who’s watching whom.

Narcissa Niblack Thorne, English Reception Room of the Jacobean Period, 1625-1655, c. 1937, Art Institute of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA.

1. Thorne Miniature Rooms — The Museum Within the Museum

📍 Art Institute of Chicago, Lower Level

Step into the basement of one of the world’s great museums, and you’ll find something almost no one talks about.

Behind a curved glass wall, 68 rooms, some no bigger than a carry-on suitcase, replicate centuries of interior design in obsessive detail. Each scene is historically accurate, from Jacobean England to Colonial New England. Every candle, drape, and doll-sized drawer was crafted to scale, with materials that would be extravagant even at full size.

It’s silent down here.

Most visitors overlook it entirely. But for those who linger, the rewards are eerie: a glimpse into frozen lives, permanently staged but never lived. Macro lenses love it, and so do fans of the uncanny. It’s Chicago’s quietest portal.

Local tip: Go early. It’s best experienced alone or nearly so. Bring a zoom lens or just your eyes, either way, it rewards close looking.

2. Fine Arts Building Elevators — Human-Powered Nostalgia

📍 410 S Michigan Ave

Most Chicago elevators stopped requiring human hands somewhere around the Kennedy administration.

Not here.

Inside this 1898 arts building, which is still home to piano tuners and violin makers, you’ll find the last manually operated elevators in town. A gloved attendant pulls the levers, watches the floors, and chats, if you’re lucky.

You’re climbing up and traveling back in time.

Each floor holds its own charming surprises, like open-door rehearsal halls and a faint smell of linseed oil. The museum is alive. And in its own way, radical: a building resisting optimization.

Pair it with: A matinee at the Studebaker Theater, located within the same building, or an espresso from Hero Coffee down the block.

3. Institute for the Study of Ancient Cultures — World-Class, Crowd-Free

📍 1155 E 58th St (UChicago Campus)

Formerly the Oriental Institute, this compact museum holds a rare kind of magic: global antiquities in a neighborhood museum setting, free of noise and selfie sticks.

You can stand inches from a 40-ton lamassu (winged Assyrian bull), decipher cylinder seals from Mesopotamia, and stare into the face of a 3,000-year-old mummy in absolute silence.

No velvet ropes or commercial trappings. Just you and a fragment of the Dead Sea Scrolls.

Its modest size is a virtue. You can see everything in an hour, and for visitors used to the echo chamber of mainstream tourism, that intimacy can feel like privilege.

Photogenic moment: The lighting on the sarcophagus casts dramatic shadows without needing filters. But ask before you snap, keep in mind that policies vary.

Creepy-Cool & Earnestly Odd: For the Curious & the Macabre

These aren’t sanitized, curated attractions. They’re raw, sometimes unsettling, but always memorable.

Sculptures by Louis Linck and Edouard Chassaing in the Hall of Immortals at the International Museum of Surgical Science

4. International Museum of Surgical Science — Gilded Age Meets Bone Dust

📍 1524 N Lake Shore Dr

Inside a historic lakefront mansion once meant for millionaires, you’ll find a collection that would make a pathologist grin.

Antique surgical instruments, including 19th-century amputation kits, and medical diagrams rendered in unflinching detail line the wood-paneled halls. There’s a prosthetic limb gallery, a re-creation of a historic operating theater, and even a room dedicated to medical quackery.

What makes it truly unforgettable, beyond the shock, is the contrast. A golden staircase opens into a room full of trepanning tools, with French chandeliers hanging over spinal cord diagrams. It’s science wrapped in finery, and it dares you to look closely.

Best time to visit: Late afternoon, when the light slants through stained glass.

5. Intuit: The Center for Intuitive and Outsider Art — Art Without Permission

📍 756 N Milwaukee Ave

Not all great art comes from art schools.

Intuit is a compact, unassuming space dedicated to creators who never asked for permission, think self-taught artists and visionaries.

Some works are obsessive, including but certainly not limited to the entire worlds built from bottle caps, twine, or found metal. Others are deeply personal and sometimes disturbing.

Expect to be challenged. Expect to linger.

Most visitors discover it by accident.

But the regulars? They come to feel something unfiltered. Redditors have called it “raw and earnest,” and they’re right, this place doesn’t try to impress you. It simply invites you to witness something real.

Don’t miss: The Henry Darger Room Collection, a re-creation of the reclusive janitor’s Chicago apartment, complete with pages from his 15,000-page illustrated epic.

6. Bachelor’s Grove Cemetery — The City’s Most Famous Ghost Story

📍 Midlothian Turnpike, Rubio Woods Forest Preserve

Wander away from Chicago proper into an abandoned, half-swallowed by forest. Widely believed to be haunted, Bachelor’s Grove is the rare Chicago-area site that feels truly off the map.

The path in is unmarked. The headstones are cracked or missing. Stories of a “phantom farmhouse” and vanishing figures persist across decades of folklore.

But despite the paranormal fame, the actual visit feels eerily peaceful. It’s a short hike from the roadside, easy to find if you know where to look, impossible if you don’t.

Arrive in daylight, ideally during golden hour, and you’ll get the full effect: a forgotten resting place reclaimed by trees and silence.

For thrill-seekers only: Night visits are illegal (and unwise), but even at noon the place has atmosphere. Bring a camera.

Eat With a Backstory: Dining as Discovery, Where What You Eat Is Only Half the Adventure

In a city as food-obsessed as Chicago, the real intrigue begins where the hype ends. The following spots are not on everyone’s itinerary—which is precisely the point.

Beyond cuisine or price point, patrons can delight in the narrative: a hidden entrance or a legend baked into the recipe.

7. Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Co. — The Flip Heard ’Round Lincoln Park

📍 2121 N Clark St

Hot pies! Inverted, in piping-hot bowls, flipped with the flourish of a server’s wrist at your table. Thick and molten, the dish is part pizza, part lava flow. It’s odd and delicious. Plus, it’s extremely photogenic.

The brownstone that houses it is rumored to have once served as a lookout point during the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre. No signs mark it; no reservations are taken. You simply show up, wait (often a long time), and hope to be let in.

Arrive just before opening to shorten your wait. The dim, wood-paneled interior feels like a speakeasy with mozzarella.

8. Oasis Café — Falafel Through the Looking Glass

📍 21 N Wabash Ave (Back of a Jewelry Mall)

You won’t see it from the street. Walk through the mall off Wabash, and past the glittering necklaces, you’ll find a plain door at the back. Push the door open to discover one of the Loop’s best-kept lunch secrets: a humble Middle Eastern counter that’s been feeding jewelers, traders, and savvy locals for years.

What makes Oasis unforgettable, besides its crisp hummus and generous portions, is how it feels like a culinary speakeasy. There’s no signage or performative “hidden gem” branding; just a warm, fragrant room tucked between showcases of diamonds.

9. Blue Bayou — Resurrection of a Dive (and the Po’boy With It)

📍 3734 N Southport Ave

After a 13-year hiatus, Blue Bayou returned to the Southport Corridor with po’boys and crawfish étouffée.

Inside, it’s all wood booths and low light. It’s filled with regulars. There’s a jukebox. The food is honest and unpretentious, sticking close to New Orleans comfort classics with just enough Chicago attitude.

Catch a retro screening or horror flick at the Music Box next door, then drift across the street for gumbo and a bourbon.

10. Qiao Lin Hotpot — Boil Your Own Adventure

📍 Multiple locations: Chinatown, Magnificent Mile

Hotpot may not be unique on its own, but Qiao Lin elevates it to an experience. You choose the broth (mala is fiery and addictive), then add everything from lotus root to lamb shoulder, cooking it all in bubbling tabletop cauldrons.

It’s DIY dining with just enough chaos.

The interiors feel sleek and moody, designed for both comfort and aesthetics. And though it’s located in high-traffic areas, it still feels like something you stumbled into on your own.

Redditors call it a “foodie playground.” They’re not wrong.

Interactive Secrets & Flash-Mob Fun, Because Watching Is Fine, But Doing Is Better

Most of these spots draw a crowd solely by word of mouth, because they offer something rare: interaction with the city itself.

11. Chicago Magic Lounge — Enter Through the Washing Machine

📍 5050 N Clark St

First, you’ll walk into a faux laundromat, then you’ll spin a few knobs, pull the right door, and suddenly you’re inside a 1930s-style magic theater.

Chicago Magic Lounge is one of the city’s best immersive experiences; part cocktail bar, part stage show.

Before the main performance begins, magicians wander the bar performing sleight-of-hand inches from your face. The building itself is a trick, and that sense of transformation carries through every act.

Insider tip: Book tickets in advance and arrive early because some of the best magic happens before the stage lights go up. Dress like you’re going somewhere worth remembering.

12. Friday Morning Swim Club — Sunrise, No RSVP

📍 Montrose Beach (Fridays, Sunrise – Summer Only)

No tickets or a website (at least as we’re writing this). Just a loose collective of early risers plunging into Lake Michigan at daybreak on Fridays, usually from June through September.

Started as a small group of friends, it’s grown—slightly—but still manages to feel like a secret society, especially when the skyline begins to glow behind you.

There are no official rules, but a few rituals: bring a towel, good vibes, and maybe coffee.

Where to find them: Follow @fridaymorningswimclub on Instagram for exact times and updates. It’s ephemeral, and that’s part of the appeal.

Build Your Own Discovery Day: Three Immersive Paths Through Chicago’s Lesser-Known Side

Combine the list of unique things to do into an unforgettable Chicago experience.

Each of these itineraries is modular by design. You can follow one straight through or combine elements across them.

Either way, what you’ll experience is Chicago’s lesser-known geography with its deeper texture, layered slowly and revealed through doing.

The Threadbare and Surreal

This itinerary is for those who find wonder in the miniature and the strangely beautiful:

• Begin at the Thorne Miniature Rooms (Art Institute of Chicago): Dozens of hyper-detailed rooms—dollhouse-sized replicas of historic interiors—tucked into a quiet basement gallery. Unsettling in their precision, these rooms reward close attention and quiet immersion.
• Lunch at Oasis Café (Loop): Hidden inside the back of a downtown jewelry mall, this Middle Eastern lunch counter serves excellent falafel and shawarma to those who know how to find it. The joy is in both the food and the finding.
• Afternoon at Intuit: The Center for Intuitive and Outsider Art (West Town): Featuring raw, self-taught, often compulsive work from creators outside the traditional art world, this museum is small but powerful. The Henry Darger Room alone is worth the visit.
• Optional add-on: Explore the Fine Arts Building (Loop): Ride the last manually operated elevators in the city, and if you find an open artist studio, step inside.

The Beautifully Macabre

Drawn to history’s darker corners and stories that linger long after the tour ends? This one’s for you:

• Start with a visit to Bachelor’s Grove Cemetery (Midlothian): Located in a forest preserve just outside the city, this semi-abandoned burial ground is steeped in ghost stories, folklore, and urban legend. Daylight hours are best and enough to feel the atmosphere shift.
• Lunch at Blue Bayou (Southport Corridor): Revived after more than a decade, this New Orleans-style spot offers po’boys, gumbo, and unapologetic comfort food. Across the street, the historic Music Box Theatre adds an extra layer of vintage charm.
• Afternoon at the International Museum of Surgical Science (Gold Coast): Set in a 1917 mansion, this offbeat museum displays centuries of medical instruments, diagrams, and prosthetics with both gravity and grace. It’s more thoughtful than shocking—and surprisingly moving.
• Optional contrast: Join Friday Morning Swim Club (Montrose Beach, summer Fridays only): A brisk sunrise swim in Lake Michigan may seem like an emotional reversal, but many find it restorative after a day steeped in the past.

The Hands-On and Hidden

This itinerary is for those who prefer participation over passive observation and experiences that don’t come prepackaged.

• Begin with lunch at Qiao Lin Hotpot (Chinatown or Magnificent Mile): Build your own bubbling cauldron of broth and fresh ingredients. It’s interactive, communal, and visually arresting—a culinary experience that asks you to create as much as consume.
• Head to the Chicago Magic Lounge (Andersonville): Enter through a fake laundromat and step into a world of sleight-of-hand, with atmospheric cocktails and stage magic that feels both intimate and grand. The performance begins before the lights go down.
• Evening wind-down at Montrose Point Bird Sanctuary (Uptown): Whether you stay dry or wade into the water, this lakeside pocket of wildness offers skyline views and a welcome decompression after a full day of immersion.

Where to Stay: Sonesta’s Take on the City

After a day spent chasing the hidden and the cinematic, your hotel should carry the mood forward.

Sonesta’s Chicago properties offer distinct personalities that reflect the city’s layered aesthetic and spirit of discovery.